Why Marketing Agencies Must Shift From Deliverables to Strategy

Catch the Full Episode Overview Back from the vault, this episode puts hard numbers behind a question many agency owners are asking right now. 9 out of 10 clients say their agency makes them more likely to succeed, and 4 out of 10 plan to scale back that relationship within a year. John Jantsch sits […]

Why Marketing Agencies Must Shift From Deliverables to Strategy written by John Jantsch read more at Duct Tape Marketing

Catch the Full Episode

Overview

Back from the vault, this episode puts hard numbers behind a question many agency owners are asking right now. 9 out of 10 clients say their agency makes them more likely to succeed, and 4 out of 10 plan to scale back that relationship within a year. John Jantsch sits down with Brian Gerstner to explain how both findings hold, and why the story is more encouraging than it first appears.

Gerstner draws on Agency Core’s 2026 study of 579 agency leaders and 400 of their clients, which looks at the attitudes behind agency success. The conversation covers agencies pulling ahead with a clear position, agencies chasing AI as an offer, and agencies still searching for direction, plus what each group means for pricing and hiring.

This episode fits agency owners, marketing consultants, and small business marketers who want to move from routine deliverables toward strategy and leadership work. Anyone weighing a niche, setting fees in the AI era, or planning a team will leave with practical direction.

Guest Bio

Brian Gerstner is co-founder of Agency Core, an independent research initiative that looks inside agencies to see how their attitudes shape their results. He is also president of White Label IQ, a 90-person team that works exclusively with agencies, and has spent more than 20 years in the agency business.

Key Takeaways

  • A niche does not have to be an industry. A region, an attitude, or a strategic approach gives an agency the focus that sets it apart.
  • Authority is built in public. Speaking, writing, and creating content around a position, then having others describe your agency as the go-to in that area, is what establishes a confident differentiator.
  • Pricing power is still available. About 29% of clients expect lower fees because of AI, yet clients will pay more for higher levels of expertise in a specific area, and marketing budgets across the industry are still growing.
  • Clients arrive with different questions now. They have moved from asking about deliverables and technical services to asking how to approach a problem and whether to pursue it at all.
  • Hiring is shifting. Even with plenty of agency attrition, hiring has become harder, and agencies need strategic thinkers who can grow into leaders since production work can be outsourced.

Great Moments

  • [03:49] – What the study measures: how confident agencies feel about their relevance, justifying their fees, and the threat AI poses to their model
  • [05:49] – Jantsch cites that only 13 to 16% of agency owners fully execute their own top priorities, and Gerstner reacts
  • [07:56] – Gerstner explains how 9 out of 10 clients valuing their agency and 4 out of 10 planning to scale back can both be true
  • [17:19] – Jantsch’s client exercise: sorting a thousand clients to find the 20% band that produces 80% of the business
  • [18:54] – Gerstner on how the agency conversation shifted in a single year from “are we relevant” to “we are relevant”

Memorable Quotes

  • “Coming in the strategy door is a far better relationship with the client than coming in the vendor do-this-thing door.” – John Jantsch
  • “If someone comes up to you and in your heart you know you can help them and they have a big bag of money in their hands, my goodness, take it.” – Brian Gerstner
  • “People are running really fast, but where are you going? There’s a reason the compass was invented before the clock. It’s because it’s more important to know where you’re going.” – Brian Gerstner
  • “To be in this industry you have to have some significant moxie to show up every day. Someone’s moving your cheese every day, every hour.” – Brian Gerstner
  • “If you focus down, if you niche in, if you lean into an area, it is an investment. It’s hard. Growth is painful.” – Brian Gerstner

Resources

 

Recommended Story For You :

Secrets Of The Big Dogs

Secrets Of The Big Dogs

John Thornhill's Ambassador Program

John Thornhill's Ambassador Program

Ewen Chia's 10 Minute Cash System

Ewen Chia's 10 Minute Cash System

Online Success Coaching

Online Success Coaching

Remixable

Remixable

Prezentar

Prezentar

The Instant AI Agency

The Instant AI Agency

SaleHoo

SaleHoo

BrandBox

BrandBox

AI Marketers Club

AI Marketers Club

Leave a Reply